Mesa Boogie aka Randall Smith started out in a small way, in fact in a shed; but he was destined for better things, and like Paul Reed Smith, Carlos Santana got the ball really rocking for Mesa Boogie.
Mesa Boogie is the master of Amplifier and Amp making in the world! What? You don't believe me?
Well if not, you may have a lot to learn so without hesitation read on.
Firstly, the above comments might set your heart racing, especially if you disagree with what I say here (or maybe you are an Axe-FX guy). There's no doubt that guitar amps and makes are a very emotive subject; and sometimes, the difference of a particular brand against another brand is so minuscule (both on build quality and sound) that to tell you the truth, you really can't tell the difference.
There are some out there that are a bit like audiophiles; what do i mean? There's nothing wrong with audiophiles; the guys who can tell you that the mains voltage has changed by 5 volts at 20 paces on their HI Fi Amp. In fact that's an awesome ability. But come on, extend this logic to a guitar amp? To convince someone of that is like saying you climbed mount Everest in your shorts in a day; frankly you are going to be the laughing stock of the guitar world maybe (or are you?). My opinion is that you will be; now that's out of the way, read on.
Mesa pioneering; click for a larger view
It's a bold statement; but bear in mind I have used, played, stripped down and even bought most of the amps out there at one time or another and I still have many of them here; so you could say, that I am capable of such a statement, but do I really mean what I say? When you have Marshall, Engl, Soldano, Egnater, Randall, Bogner, Splawn, Mesa Boogie and you know the names of the rest like I do, they are emblazoned in our memory right? Those amps we all dream about (some more than others) but they are all something to aspire to in our lives; I want a *********; we have all said it.
But when you have that amp that cost you years to save for, and it fails, or just does not sound like you thought then disillusionment sets in and you are all set to lose some money. Surely Mesa Boogie amps are not that good? Are they the worlds premiere amp? Well it all depends what you are trying to do with them, and like many brands each amp has a unique calling card usually for a particular style of playing so the selection of the right amp is paramount in you getting what you want; and that's the same for all amps.
But there is really a few places where amps really are different and I summarize below where they are most variable:
- Quality of the components
- Quality of the build of the amplifier
- The design of the amp
- How robust is the design for real world situations
- After sales warranty and support
You see, you probably knew that already. If you have ever had a problem with your amp then you will know first hand about some of the above; and indeed your problem could have involved every point in that list; yes, it can be that bad. Now I know some guys will disagree with what I say here, they might have had problems with mesa Boogie in the past, or present, but one thing is most likely to be true; from that list above, go on, be serious, how many of you have had a Mesa Amp that suffers from all those points; stop, let me tell you... not a single user.
Now, compare that with other amplifier makers. Let's talk Marshall for a while. Here's just one example. The JCM2000 had a socket on the back of the PCB that was for the foot switch. That connector either became loose, cracked on the main board, or just simply stopped working exactly when you wanted it to work the most. The reason was simple; that design failed in the list above on 1, 2, 3, and 4. It's true marshall would fix the amp, but it's also true that if you have a bad design, component or other aspect that's in the amp just waiting to fail, then it will and this is just one example of bad design. Actually I love Marshall. You can I am sure think of thousands of problems you have heard of, some easily and rapidly fixed, others linger on for a while, but if you design, build and make with decent components from tried and tested methods its likely you will make a winner (especially if it sounds right).
Click for larger view
In the early 90's Mesa Boogie reinvented itself with the Triaxis Preamp and the 2:90 power amp; they were getting a bit stale before that; the Mark III was long in the tooth. The Triaxis was rapidly followed up by the RECTIFIER tube amps that changed so many things in guitar amplification you could lose count of them all and Randall Smith was right there doing the inventing. How many amps can you name that emulate a rectifier in one way or another? Engl, Randall, Bogner, Splawn, Hughes & Kettner, the list will go on and on; and you will know what I am getting at here; if you invent a winner everyone copies you; in another context think about PRS and the 'single cut'; a Gibson based design and today I am sure that it's hurting Gibson.
But it is a pity in the case of amplifier design. Randall Smith is lucky to have patented the original designs, but other manufacturers will work around the patents. But they don't work around the things in that list above. Usually one thing or another will be missed off that list to reduce cost and so compete with what they are in fact emulating a Mesa Boogie design. And you know what, we all suffer because of that.
Here are the main reasons why I think Mesa Boogie amps are in fact probably the best mass produced amplifier for guitar with a price/performance that others would dearly like to match:
- The design. Randall Smith is no fool. Even today, the PCB's that they make are all basically hand drawn right there on the design board. You will notice (if you look at a Mesa board) that many of the corners in the tracks are rounded like someone actually drew them by hand, well they did. These days, amp makers use sophisticated software to design the main boards and that's that. Whereas Randall Smith and co will take the time to get that board EXACTLY as right as humanly possible. And if you use multilayered boards then its critical because all those tracks interact to contribute to the sound. However note that this appears less these days (2015).
- Build Quality. While it's true that Mesa do use modern production methods, it's also true that they check those builds over and over again and that's just one reason why these amps are so damn good.
- The components. Mesa Boogie chooses really high quality components for inside their amps. These are far less likely to fail early. While it's true you can name many other makers that are also very careful with what goes in to the amp, there's no denying the quality from Mesa regarding components.
- Solid build. Mesa Boogie used to show how robust their amps were - they used to trawl around some pictures of amps that have fallen off the stage, or a truck, or... well you get the idea. Then they would tell you if the amp worked afterwards - and near enough all of them did. It's not unique, but very nearly so - I could not name any other manufacturer that has done this either before or after Mesa Boogie.
- After Sales Warranty and Support. Every amp maker has to offer this - amps do blow up, fail in service, get abused, dropped, and so on - it's a fact of life. Some amps fail early on, and others run for years without problems - but there's one thing for sure - sooner or later you WILL need those guys. And, depending on if they really are as good as their word - your problem will get fixed. If its a design problem, you will be back. If its cheap components - you will be back, if its a bad case of thrown together - you will be back.
The truth is, like everyone else I have had trouble with Mesa Boogie amps and here's the examples:
- Mark III Combo: This amp failed about four hours from taking delivery of the amp. The fault showed up as crackling in the amp speaker (almost like a bang and very loud). It was determined to be a faulty tube socket but they replaced the amp immediately.
- Mark IV Combo: Towards about 6 years the amp started to make lots of pops in the speakers; this was later determined to be tubes. Although the tubes had been changed about 6 months prior these failed prematurely.
- Triaxis Preamp: I paid a small fortune for this new. After about 3 months the covering that is on the front of the preamp started lifting. It was a known problem. They replaced the front and I never had another issue with that preamp. Actually the failure of the front cover was due to oily deposits on the case of the preamp which over time lifted the cover.
I have owned: Mark III, Mark IV, Triaxis, 2:90 Power Amp, Road King Mk I, Two Triple Rectifiers, a Road King Mk II, an Electra Dyne and a Royal Atlantic. The only faults to date are as listed above. In each and every case the problems were resolved fast and at Mesa Boogie's expense. There are of course some things I don't like about Mesa too!
Click for a larger view
As many readers will know, choices of amps are a personal thing, and some readers will prefer other brands, for sound, feel or a thousand other reasons. One of the most annoying thing about Mesa Boogie in fact here in the UK is the absolutely EXTORTIONATE price we have to pay for those amps; it's exactly the opposite with marshall amps; while over in the USA Marshall are coveted - as Mesa are here. This distorts (in a bad way) the value of the equipment to guitarists in their respective countries. Mesa don't fix that, but it's long overdue that they should.
I noticed that Marshall have just parted ways with Korg in the USA for distribution and are taking on the distribution of Marshall amps themselves; indeed just as they did in the UK all those years ago with Rose Morris. Hopefully the USA will see better pricing now the middle man is out of the way. But the middle man for Mesa Boogie is still here in the UK? Wake up Mesa maybe you would sell many more units if the price was the same as the USA street prices.
Triple rectifier amp
So I am nearing the end of this long page on this website but, you know what, I still think Mesa Boogie remains the premiere world leader in amp design, quality and support even if you do have to pay more here in the UK. I hate Westside (the Mesa Boogie distributor in the UK) and will never buy a UK Mesa amp again because of the ridiculous retail prices these guys sting us all for. It's just cheaper to ship from the USA and use a drop down transformer. I really hope that you guys have a think about what you want from an amp? is it what I say here? or do you have a completely different criteria for your amp choices?
One things for sure the following list may well be the reasons you buy yours; these are why I buy mine:
- Sound: it's got to sound right
- Design: can it hack what I need
- Quality: components and build really matter for a keeper amp
- Price: often moved up the list but usually a contributor to compromised sound
- Innovation: does this amp offer something no other amp does
- Warranty: I always read the fine print it could save you a fortune later
I'm at the end of some of the reasons why Mesa Boogie rules. My other amps are all cool in different ways and I recommend many of those too; but the favorite amp falls back to Mesa products simply because of the above. Of course, they are not for everyone, and many guys don't like the sounds from Mesa Boogie; but that's a subjective decision; badly designed products, with poor quality and really bad warranty is not. If you disagree with any of this you have the right to and that's no problem either. These views are just from me owning many amplifiers over the years and are directly what I found personally.
Some images © Mesa Boogie.
© A B Mckenzie 1997-2021. All Rights Reserved